New York-Inspired Restaurants and Businesses in Naples, Florida
Naples, Florida is known for its sunny beaches, luxury living, and vibrant food scene — but did you know it’s also home to several New York-inspired restaurants and businesses? From bagels and pizza to classic deli sandwiches, Naples has captured the flavors of the Big Apple right here in Southwest Florida.
Whether you’re a transplanted New Yorker craving a taste of home, or just looking for a unique culinary experience, here’s where to get your New York fix in Naples.
1. Brooklyn Dough – Authentic New York Bagels
📍 935 3rd Avenue North, Naples, FL
Brooklyn Dough brings authentic Brooklyn bagels to Naples. Hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked fresh daily, these bagels are exactly what you’d expect from a true New York bagel shop. Favorites include classic bacon, egg, and cheese sandwiches, as well as cream cheese spreads and fresh pastries.
Why it’s a must-visit:
Authentic New York-style bagels.
Cozy, friendly atmosphere.
Perfect for breakfast, brunch, or takeout for a sunny beach day.
2. NYPP New York Pizza & Pasta – Big City Flavor
📍 11140 Tamiami Trail N, Naples, FL
NYPP offers the quintessential New York pizza experience with a thin, foldable crust and generous toppings. Beyond pizza, the menu includes hearty pasta dishes, Italian-American classics, and sandwiches that make you feel like you’re in Manhattan.
Why it’s a must-visit:
Family-friendly and casual dining.
Authentic NYC pizza flavor.
Full Italian-American menu for all tastes.
3. Santi’s New York Pizza – Slice by Slice
📍 7087 Radio Road, Naples, FL
Santi’s New York Pizza captures the NYC neighborhood pizzeria vibe. With pizza by the slice, whole pies, and classic Italian-American dishes, it’s perfect for a quick meal or casual dinner.
Why it’s a must-visit:
Quick, satisfying New York-style pizza.
Cozy, no-frills atmosphere.
Great for takeout or casual dining with friends.
4. Katz New York Deli – Classic NYC Deli Fare
Katz New York Deli brings a traditional New York deli experience to Naples. Think pastrami sandwiches, matzo ball soup, and hearty deli classics. The atmosphere features deli counters and nostalgic décor reminiscent of New York delis.
Why it’s a must-visit:
Hearty, classic New York deli sandwiches.
Perfect brunch or lunch spot.
A taste of NYC nostalgia in Southwest Florida.
Final Thoughts
If you’re craving a slice of New York while enjoying the sunny Naples lifestyle, these New York-inspired restaurants and businesses won’t disappoint. From Brooklyn-style bagels to classic pizzeria pies and deli sandwiches, Naples offers an authentic taste of the Big Apple — without leaving Florida.
Whether you’re a local or visiting Southwest Florida, make sure to add these spots to your culinary tour of Naples — it’s the perfect way to enjoy a little bit of NYC in paradise.
Planning a move to Naples? I can guide you to neighborhoods near these iconic eateries so you’re never far from your New York favorites in the Sunshine State.
