New Chicago Sandwich Shop Opens In Downtown Naples!
Naples just got a serious upgrade to its lunch scene. Meet All Too Well — a gourmet sandwich shop bringing bold flavors, chef-driven creativity, and a touch of Chicago to the heart of downtown.
Located just off 5th Avenue South, this fast-casual concept is anything but ordinary. It’s the kind of place where a quick lunch turns into “wait…this is actually incredible.”
Not Your Average Sandwich Shop
At first glance, All Too Well may seem like a simple deli—but the difference is in the details. Every sandwich is built on schiacciata, a thinner, crispier cousin of focaccia that adds the perfect crunch without overwhelming the ingredients.
Inside, the space is intentionally small and intimate, with limited seating—making it feel more like a hidden gem than a big chain spot.
The concept? Elevated sandwiches with premium ingredients, global inspiration, and chef-level execution.
A Menu That Feels Elevated (and Unexpected)
This is where All Too Well really stands out. The menu blends classic deli roots with Mediterranean and global flavors, creating combinations you won’t find anywhere else in Naples.
A few standout sandwiches include:
Chicago Italian Beef (reimagined) — shaved ribeye dipped in au jus, layered with garlic mayo, cheddar, and tabbouleh
Bombay Chouli — turkey, prosciutto, burrata, fig jam, and chili crunch for a sweet + spicy combo
Shredded Lamb Sandwich — rich, savory, and deeply flavorful
Everything is thoughtfully crafted, from house-made condiments (like pomegranate mustard seeds) to unique ingredient pairings.
The Story Behind the Name
All Too Well isn’t just a catchy name—it’s rooted in family history.
Founder Mitchell Aboujamra comes from a long line of butchers and deli owners, and this concept is his modern take on the neighborhood sandwich shop he grew up around.
The idea is simple:
take classic sandwiches and make them the best version they can possibly be.
And yes—the name is inspired by the song (but that’s where the connection ends 😉).
Why It’s Worth the Hype in Naples
Naples has no shortage of sandwich spots—but All Too Well fills a gap that didn’t quite exist before:
Elevated, chef-driven sandwiches
Unique, globally inspired flavors
A quick, casual format that still feels premium
It’s perfect for:
A quick lunch after the beach
A casual downtown bite
Or when you’re craving something different from the usual sub shop rotation
Final Thoughts
All Too Well is one of those places that feels like it belongs in a bigger food city—but somehow landed right here in Naples.
It’s fresh, creative, and exactly the kind of spot locals and visitors will keep coming back to.
If you’re someone who loves good food (and not just good-for-Naples food), this one’s worth checking out ASAP.
